Violence & Vigilance by David T. List

Violence & Vigilance is book one of Turesia Untamed, an epic fantasy series featuring an eternal vendetta, scars of grief and loss, untethered rage, and hope against all odds.

Irdessa the Undying, a renowned arena fighter in Fohrvylda, has escaped imprisonment but at great cost. Broken and alone, she must outwit and outfight her pursuers.

Basalt Kale, a failed Consonant monk of the lowest order, embarks on a quest to improve Ausgan but discovers vile secrets of his order that he cannot abide.

The heathens of Fohrvylda amass ships and beasts of war to sail the Faithless Sea and assault the monks of Ausgan, who will greet the steel-bearing invaders with elemental destruction.

Violence & Vigilance is a story of survival with dark humor, exotic settings, savage beasts, and damaged characters. If you enjoy the grittiness of Joe Abercrombie’s First Law or the urgency of Pierce Brown’s Red Rising, you’ll love Violence & Vigilance.


Seventh up in our run through the SPFBO Finals is Violence & Vigilance by David T. List, and it’s dark, bloody and brutal in all the ways grimdark fans hope for. Most of us got swept up in a world full of strange beasts and cultures, and a surprising number of us fell hard for a drunk, crusty thief we never expected to love. It wasn’t for everyone, though, and one of us stepped away early. Here’s what we thought.

Kerry

I read this book whilst stuck in a hospital bed and for me V & V was the best dark epic fantasy that I’ve read in some time that was just pure escapism. It ticked so many of the boxes that I enjoy in epic fantasy and it felt like it was written with people like me in mind.

Great solidly built main characters with a side cast that help bring this tale to life. (#team Bravensi)

Excellent worldbuilding with some excellent and original flora and fauna and a magic system that felt original.

Prose and pacing was well done and I felt the author did a great job of not letting any one story arc take precedence over another.

This came very close to a 5 star read but there was a couple of minor plot holes within the magic that left a constant niggle and whilst I did like the way Irdessa was written, there was just something about her that got under my skin. If anyone should have been an annoying character, it was Kraus but he turned out to be one of my absolute favourites.

Really excited for book 2, especially after the last explosive 10-20% of Violence and Vigilance. David List has written something truly stellar in a beautifully dark style.

Julia

Violence & Vigilance by David T. List is epic, dark, and bloody, and I loved every brutal minute of it. This is grimdark done right.

Irdessa is the standout for me. She’s a skilled fighter through and through, never one to back down from a fight. What sneaks up on her isn’t the violence, it’s the leading. She never sets out to become anyone’s leader. It just happens, one decision at a time, until she looks around one day and realizes people are following her. Watching that unfold felt real and earned in a way a lot of chosen hero arcs never quite manage.

Then there’s Kraus, and honestly, I didn’t see this coming. He’s no white knight. He’s introduced to the cast looking worse than he really is, and the saddest part is he can’t even defend himself properly, because the drink has eaten away enough of his memory that he doesn’t fully trust his own past either. He’s the kind of man who’d stay loyal to the death one moment and rob you blind the next, wrestling with who he is while barely caring whether he lives to see tomorrow. That contradiction is what makes him so magnetic. By the end he’d become one of my favorite characters in the whole book, and I did not expect that going in.

Kale rounds out the trio nicely, even if his arc follows a familiar shape, a young man slowly waking up to a bigger destiny than the order that raised him ever let him believe. In another book that might have felt tired. Here it works like a breath of air, a bit of light poking through all the darkness around him.

But the world is what truly pulled me in and kept me there. It never feels like scenery. New beasts, races, and cultures keep surfacing, and it genuinely feels like something is waiting behind every tree. It’s a rare kind of fantasy setting, one that feels lived in rather than built for the story to walk through.

Actual romance stays light, but moments of temptation and sex show up more than I would have liked. One character has real mind reading magic, and it works better on someone distracted than someone locked in on a single thought, so she uses her body to throw men off balance and slip inside their heads, made sharper by the fact that carnal touch is a sin for the monks she’s working on. That’s just one thread in a wider pattern though, alongside a detailed sex scene that was well written but more than I needed, and a few other moments built around chasing women or sex as a reward. None of it lingers for long, but it surfaced often enough to occasionally pull me out of the story.

The pacing takes its time too. The world is big and the characters strong enough that I was happily reading from the very first pages, but the book doesn’t fully sink its claws in until the back half, and especially the final third.

Grimdark with real teeth and real heart. It takes a while to sink those teeth in, but once it does, it doesn’t let go, and you’ll be turning pages long after you meant to stop.

Adawia

I love when an author can get me to cheer for the crusty, violent thief. And in my experience, the best way to do that is pit him against even more violent, corrupt, government officials – that’ll pretty much do it every time. I think it’s the sheer injustice. Punish a man for his crimes, fine, good even. But, if you’re acting like the good guys, and are supposed to be bringing justice while you grape and pillage across the country and blaming others for your crimes just for the accolades, promotions, and extra financial rewards ….. nah! I’m gonna enjoy watching you receive all the comeuppance you deserve. So that’s Kraus – equal parts brave and stupid, humble and proud, and ultimately loyal (to those who deserve his loyalty). He’s a tough bastard, and I kinda wanna be his friend (violent tendencies notwithstanding).

Another thing I love about this book is the multiple POVs. Especially the random ones that may only last a few pages but give us a new and unique perspective to the prevailing situation (quite often, the current battle). They’re like micro stories within the main thread that provide insight and perspective without distracting from the action.

I struggled a fair bit with the imagery. Even with all the descriptions and details, I wasn’t really able to form clear pictures of the landscapes, buildings, (which play a fairly integral role) or characters, but mostly I struggled with the compass – this is one book I feel would benefit from the inclusion of a map, or two.

Now, I don’t expect the end of a book one to be tied up prettily and completely in a bow, but I did feel that a couple things should have been dealt with a little more before the conclusion of this leg of the story. I can’t really go into detail without giving spoilers, but suffice to say that some things were left hanging, and not in a way that felt like a good place to leave off, but more like they’d been forgotten about. Nothing too serious, and I still think this story is excellent, but I was left wondering what happened to…….

EG

DNF’d after prologue and ½ of ch 1. I don’t read books where a character, especially a female character, exists solely for the purpose of being assaulted, as was the case in the prologue. Immediate DNF.


That’s our take on Violence & Vigilance! Plenty of bite, a world that kept surprising us, and a battered, unlikely hero who stole more than one heart. A slow start, a few loose threads and the odd scene that pulled us out kept it from a clean sweep, and the brutal prologue was a hard stop for one of us. But those who pushed on came away eager for book two.

Our Official SPFBO Score: 8/10

No rounding needed this time: the average landed on a perfectly even 8.

Violence & Vigilance is one of the ten finalists in this year’s SPFBO. Here’s how our current standings look:

A huge thank you to David T. List for putting this book forward, and to all the other teams working through the Finals alongside us. Stay tuned as the scores come in for the rest. You can see the list of all the finalists and their scores here.

Our judges for Round Two are Adawia, EG, EVA, Kerry, Maureen, Max, Sara, Sherry, Stacey, Tianna, Yaniv, and Julia (me). If you’d like to learn more about us, including our likes and dislikes, you can read about them here.

Any queries should be directed at our editor, Jennie Ivins, via Bluesky, Instagram, or Threads.

Share

By Julia Kitvaria Sarene

Julia Kitvaria Sarene, a Munich native with an unmistakable love for all things fantasy, spent a solid 21 years working as a bookseller. During that time, she became a veritable wizard of book recommendations, guiding countless customers to their next literary adventure. In fact, if you ever walked into a bookshop and heard a voice telling you, “You’ll love this one,” you were probably in her domain. Her heart beats for fantasy novels, but don’t try to talk her into romance. She’s far too busy exploring epic worlds where dragons are more common than love triangles. As a reviewer for Fantasy Faction, Julia brings her enthusiasm and humor to older books as well as the latest fantasy releases, trying to help readers navigate the realm of swords, magic, and supernatural wonders. When she’s not nose-deep in a book or battling the occasional villainous creature on paper, Julia can be found out in the wilds, either running, hiking, or practicing traditional archery. Yes, she’s one of those rare individuals who can probably lose an arrow while discussing the latest fantasy tome. (Loose as in go looking for it, rather than shoot, as she has much more love than talent for archery.) Her adventure doesn’t stop there, she’s also a proud owner of a cute black rescue dog who’s probably the only one who truly understands the complexities of her ever-growing book collection. And if you think her book obsession is a problem, think again. Julia’s collection has reached legendary proportions. She buys more books than any one person can read in a lifetime. No such thing as “too many” books in her world. Since her eyesight is on the decline (a tragic side effect of loving books a little too much), she’s a devoted fan of audiobooks, embracing the power of storytelling in every possible format. So, whether she’s running through forests, reviewing fantasy novels, or playing with Galli, Julia is living proof that life is too short to not enjoy a good adventure, be it in the real world or between the pages of a fantastical story.