Editor’s Note: Fantasy encompasses a HUGE body of works. There is literally something in fantasy for everyone. But where to begin if you’ve never tried fantasy before? Here is one reader’s picks for first time fantasy readers. As with all lists, your mileage may vary. Let us know your picks in the comments!
If a reader wanted to dive into the romance genre, they might start with Pride and Prejudice. If they aspired to read a thriller, they might give The Da Vinci Code a try.
The fantasy genre is unlike any other. It has a long and glorious history as well as a healthy population of new, popular titles and future classics. So where to start in fantasy? There are so many wonderful books out in the world, it’s nearly impossible to decide.
For each sub-genre, I’ve identified the single title I believe would be the perfect starting point for a reader looking to jump in with both feet. These books are representative of their sub-genre, easy, ap
proachable reads, and books that can be a stepping stone to other amazing stories. Here it goes!
Classic Fantasy
I’m sure most would expect The Hobbit to be book number one on the list for classic fantasy. And sure, it makes the back-up list. But The Hobbit can be off-putting with its dense language and slow start. Instead, I’m recommending A Wizard of Earthsea by none other than the fabulous Ursula K. Le Guin.
Sparrowhawk’s journey from boy to man is relatable and nuanced, and his island-by-island exploration of the Archipelago make for the perfect starting place for classic fantasy.
Back-up Titles: The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien and Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K. Dick
Literary Fantasy
Now, I’ll admit. Literary titles are not really my jam. I find them long-winded, preachy, and slow. But there are still winners to be found within the literary fantasy sub-genre. Case and point: The Ocean at the End of the Lane.
Neil Gaiman’s prose is utterly delightful, and this story of an unnamed man reflecting on his childhood is sure to tug the heartstrings of every reader. Add that with a short book that clocks in under 200 pages and you’ve got a winner!
Back-up Title: The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho
Historical Fantasy
One of my favorite and one of the quietest sub-genres of fantasy is historical fantasy. These books take place in a real period of time but include clear fantasy elements. History itself isn’t the most exciting of topics for most, so books in the historical fantasy genre have to find a way to bring the reader into the past in unique and interesting ways.
The Golem and the Jinni by Helene Wecker accomplishes all this in spectacular fashion. Taking place in turn-of-the-19th Century New York, readers meet a golem in the Jewish community who befriends a jinni freed from his lamp and living in the Middle Eastern community. Balancing the cultures, histories, and fantasy elements in a compelling story is what puts The Golem and the Jinni on the list.
Back-up Titles: The Scorpio Races by Maggie Stiefvater and The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern
Middle Grade Fantasy
Yes, we’re all adults here. And yes, several of these titles are young adult. But reading middle grade fantasy gives us the opportunity to experience stories that are simpler in both plot and language, but still accomplish all that adult and young adult books do.
The Giver by Lois Lowry has been a favorite of mine for something like twenty years. It’s a staple in middle-school classes and for good reason! Jonas’s exploration of history and emotion is touching, and the post-apocalyptic worldbuilding make this the perfect place to get started in middle grade fantasy.
Back-up Title: The Monstrumologist by Rick Yancey
Supernatural Fantasy
Who doesn’t want to have a superpower? And who doesn’t want to read about people learning to use their superpower with varying degrees of success?
I chose Air Awakens as a great introductory novel to the supernatural fantasy sub-genre. Vhalla learning to use her powers over wind and air is the underdog story we all need. It’s easy to read but still has delightful prose. The characters fit into classic tropes while still putting a unique spin on them. Add in the addictive next four books in the series, and this one’s a winner!
Back-up Titles: Shadow and Bone by Leigh Bardugo and Rebel of the Sands by Alwyn Hamilton
Secondary-World Fantasy
Books that don’t take place on Earth? Count me in! There are thousands of stories that take place on worlds created by the author, and some of them are simply breathtaking (including the Archipelago of the Earthsea Cycle).
A Darker Shade of Magic gets this one for me. It takes place in four Londons. Not one. Not two. But FOUR Londons. And while London is a real place here on Earth, Schwab gives us three more that are decidedly elsewhere. The combination of real-world and secondary-world makes A Darker Shade of Magic a great stepping stone to the rest of the amazing books of this subgenre.
Back-up Titles: Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas and Red Queen by Victoria Aveyard
Science Fantasy
Yes, there is fantasy in space! Many of the stories that take place in space are categorized as science fiction. But in reality, many of them have elements of fantasy in them. So I’m including them here!
My recommendation for science fantasy is Orson Scott Card’s relatively unknown novel Treason. Following Lanik in his exile as a rad (a person who grows excess body parts), Treason is a bit like Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland. The reader will slowly fall into a world (or in this case, planet) that is exceedingly weirder with every page, but in all the best ways. It’s quirky and interesting and a ball of fun, and readers that enjoy it will find a full catalog of books with OSC on the front.
Back-up Titles: Illuminae by Amie Kaufman & Jay Kristoff and Artemis by Andy Weir
Romantic Fantasy
I would be untrue to myself if I made a list of must-read fantasy and didn’t include romantic fantasy. Many of the titles already mentioned include elements of romance, but others stand above the rest.
While I had a supremely difficult time narrowing this one down, I’ve got to give it to A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas. It’s a loose retelling of Beauty and the Beast and the foundation of one of the best fantasy romances out there.
Back-up Titles: Stolen Songbird by Danielle L. Jensen and Daughter of Smoke and Bone by Laini Taylor
Cultural Fantasy
Yes, all books contain some element of culture, whether real-world or secondary. But some stories embody a different culture with such clarity and completion that readers are transported to not just a place, but an ideology.
A Star-Touched Queen by Roshani Chokshi is one such read. Deep-set in Indian mythology, Maya’s world includes horoscopes, palaces with thousands of locked doors, and reincarnation pools. Add in some lovely storytelling and this is a must read!
Back-up Titles: An Ember in the Ashes by Sabaa Tahir and The Bear and the Nightingale by Katherine Arden
Contemporary Fantasy
And last but not least, the fantasy books that take place in modern times: the contemporary fantasy books! These are stories that include cell phones, subways, and cable. And this category was actually pretty easy for me. It’s got to be Lev Grossman’s The Magicians!
Between the charm of Brakebills, the relatable quirkiness of Quentin, or the dreamy book obsession of Fillory, The Magicians is a delightful dive into the world of modern fantasy reads.
Back-up Titles: Vicious by V. E. Schwab and The Raven Boys by Maggie Stiefvater
It goes without saying (and yet here I’m saying it anyway), that I’m only one person and I simply cannot read every book in every subgenre. So if you have any books to add (or subgenres to include), let me know!
