The Blue Sword by Robin McKinley
 

The Blue Sword

Review

 
The Path of Flames by Phil Tucker
 

The Path of Flames

Review

 
Lisa Tuttle Interview – The Curious Affair of the Witch at Wayside Cross
 

Lisa Tuttle

Interview - The Witch at Wayside Cross

 

Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn: A Look Back

As fantasy readers across the world wait with bated breath for the June release of The Witchwood Crown and Tad Williams’ return to the world of Osten Ard, Fantasy Faction is taking a look back at Memory, Sorrow and ThornWilliams’ seminal work of epic fantasy and the foundation for his new series, The Last King of Osten ArdThis month, we go back to the beginning having just finished a re-read of all three “MST” novels.  In the coming weeks, we’ll also review Williams’ recently released Osten Ard novella The Heart of What Was Lost, and we’ll have a review of The Witchwood Crown right around its release in late June.

I don’t remember the circumstances of every single book I’ve ever purchased.  But I vividly remember being 13 years old and receiving my first package of books from the old Science Fiction and Fantasy Book Club. Inside that box was a treasure trove of hardcovers—it might have been seven books for a penny, it might have been ten books for a dollar—manufactured under license and smaller than retail versions.  Lodged between a Fred Saberhagen novel I’ve still never read, a book by a gentleman named David Drake and the first couple Death Gate Cycle novels from Weis and Hickman were books that I can legitimately say altered the course of my literary life.  The first two were The Eye of the World and The Great HuntThe second pair was The Dragonbone Chair and The Stone of Farewell.

The Dragonbone Chair by Tad WilliamsI chose all those books based on tiny blurbs and cover photos printed in a 5” x 7” magazine that randomly showed up at my house, likely because I was a member of the old Waldenbooks Preferred Readers Club.  I had been bitten by the fantasy bug with the discovery of Dragonlance, Eddings and Lord of the Rings three or four years prior.  I read them over and over and over as only kids can.  I’d seen the Wheel of Time books at the store, but always passed on them for the latest TSR had to offer.  Williams’ work was completely unknown.  I figured for what I (meaning: my parents) was paying, I could take a few risks, buy some things that were outside of my narrow wheelhouse.

That decision is still paying dividends 25 years later.

Kurt Cobain famously said that “Smells Like Teen Spirit” was just his blatant attempt at writing a Pixies song.  The rest, as they say, was history.  One need look no further than George R.R. Martin (the Cobain to Williams’ Black Francis) to see that MST altered the landscape of fantasy.  Without Osten Ard there is no Westeros as we know it. And without A Game of Thrones, this new golden age of fantasy we’re living in simply doesn’t happen.  Memory, Sorrow and Thorn isn’t just important to me personally.  It is “capital-I” Important.

Memory, Sorrow and Thorn is the tale of Simon, the kitchen boy who goes on an adventure.  It is the tale of three great swords, a dragon and a dead king, and the twilight of the immortal Sithi.  It is a war story, a love story, a political story and a religious story.  It is about fathers and sons, mothers and daughters, husbands and wives.  Even at its most fantastic, it is deeply rooted in simple human emotion.  And even at its most triumphant, it doesn’t shy away from the sadness at the core of the tale.

Stone of Farewell by Tad WilliamsI burned through The Dragonbone Chair and The Stone of Farewell in a matter of two weeks.  I vividly remember being unable to put them down.  Those copies are still almost pristine, but there are wear marks on the map pages from constantly flipping back to get a lay of the land.  And when I finished them, the wait for To Green Angel Tower—which was nearly two years away—was excruciating.  Remember—we weren’t living in the Internet age in 1991.  I imagine the only way I determined when the third book was coming out was by constantly harassing the clerks at the Waldenbooks I rode my bike to on a near-daily basis.

To Green Angel Tower was released and it was a monster.  1,104 pages of tiny type crammed between two hardback covers.  I was ecstatic.  Here was something I could savor, I could sink my teeth into, I could live with and digest over a few months.

I finished it in two weeks.

I re-read the entire series for the first time over the last couple months, via audiobook.  Unlike many series I read as a kid, Williams’ work holds up.  It doesn’t feel trite, dated or shallow.  There’s that timelessness to it that clings to great works of fantasy.  Lord of the Rings has that feel.  So do The Wheel of Time and Harry Potter.  So does A Song of Ice and Fire.  These works exist outside of the regular narrative.  They are neither temporary nor fleeting.  They persist and have become part of the fantasy fabric.

Memory, Sorrow and Thorn could have easily failed.  The tale of an orphaned boy with a mysterious destiny has been played to death in fantasy circles.  So, too, have tales of aloof and immortal elves from a far off corner the world.  Dragons, swords, trolls, horselords, knights in shining armor, magic both black and white—these are the things from which tropes are made.  And yet Williams breathed new life into the old standbys through sheer force of will.

To Green Angel Tower by Tad WilliamsThe Dragonbone Chair, the first volume of the trilogy, is a slow burn.  Parts of it read like a linear, heavily plotted tale while other passages feel like improvisational jazz.  The reader can feel Williams finding his way, throwing ideas at the wall to see what sticks.   He seems to write in service to both the characters and the story, and isn’t one to shy away from following both down unexpected paths.  By the second book, The Stone of Farewell, Williams’ confidence in both his material and his characters’ ability to captivate a reader is on full display.  And To Green Angel Tower takes the whole thing widescreen–epic in size and scope, with payoff that satisfies as much as it surprises.

Re-reading a beloved series from childhood can be a dicey proposition.  Books that blew your mind as a kid can seem juvenile and dated through the lens of adulthood.  But my re-read of Memory, Sorrow and Thorn engendered the opposite reaction.  The books were even more enjoyable the second time around.  As a more experienced reader and with the dubious benefit of age, I find myself appreciating Williams’ “four book trilogy” even more than I did before.  After reading series like A Song of Ice and Fire, The Wheel of Time and Abercrombie’s First Law trilogy I have a deeper understanding of and respect for the risks Williams took in delving into the minutiae, and a deeper admiration of his ability to pull it off with aplomb.

Memory, Sorrow and Thorn is essential reading for any fan of the fantastic.  Whether the series is your cup of tea or not, by the end you’ll undoubtedly agree that Williams was ahead of his time.  And you’ll see his influence—both subtle and overt—in much of the best fantasy that has followed.  There’s a reason The Witchwood Crown is—by far—my most anticipated book of 2017.   Williams’ return to Osten Ard is a true fantasy Event.  And as the release of The Witchwood Crown draws close, as the buzz grows louder and louder, my fervent hope is that a new generation falls in love with this story the way I did—that they embrace it, laud it, and give it the place of honor on the collective bookshelf it so richly deserves.

Memory, Sorrow, Thorn by Tad Williams

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 10.0/10 (11 votes cast)
Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn: A Look Back, 10.0 out of 10 based on 11 ratings
Share

9 Comments

  1. Splicer says:

    I wasn’t as positive about the ending of Memory, Sorrow and Thorn. I found To Green Angel Tower padded with unnecessary characters whose sole purpose was to show up and then die. It also contained chapters where the main characters would go off on some side-quest that put them into danger and then a following chapter that got them out of the danger. If these chapters had been removed, the main storyline would have been no different. In other words, they were only there to boost the page-count.

    Then there was the ending…

    Villains who were dispatched in a way that made me say, “That’s it?” Plus a main character that makes a sacrifice that has meaning only to have it mean less.

    All-in-all, the journey was a lot better than the destination.

    • I have a feeling I know which character, in particular, you’re talking about and I do agree that her arc was a bit…abrupt. I disagree with the “unnecessary” bit, though. As far as the side-quests go, maybe the main storyline wouldn’t have been different but I’m of the opinion that the characters’ development–and my understanding thereof–may have been different. I liked the ending…particularly since we now know the story isn’t over. In any event, to each his or her own! Thanks for reading and commenting!

  2. Davieboy says:

    Thanks, great write-up, your enthusiasm really shines through! Perhaps I’ll give them a go….

  3. […] Fantasy Faction looks back at fantasy novel Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn by Tad Williams. […]

  4. […] Faction has a look back at Memory, Sorrow and Thorn in preparation for The Witchwood […]

  5. Marcus says:

    Great article. Your comment how you checked the bookshop every day for Green Angel Tower – that cracked me up as it was so like my own situation. A friend lent me Dragonbone Chair (never to get it back!) and like you, i devoured it. I then quickly bought Stone of Farewell and like you, had the painful wait for Green Angel Tower.

    I remember getting my hands on it though – it wasn’t hard cover but it was large format, with Simon & Miriamele on the front, Jiriki and…(i cant remember their names…the Sithi) on the back and damn did i love that cover. And like you, i remember how happy i was that it was not only huge – but tiny writing, aka a monster! It may not have been perfect and i’m sure we could pick bits to pieces, but for me it’s one of the best series I’ve ever read. How it stands up these days? I have no idea. I read two of Tad’s later works – that Shadowmarch trilogy and i didnt like them much. I havent re-read Memory, Sorrow and Thorn again since my teenage days as I was worried that like so many other books, it wouldnt stand the test of time.

    But for me, there were so many satisfying moments about these books. I particularly liked the resolution between Seoman & Miriamele, it was a slow-burning romance that paid off the right way i think.

    I was excited that Tad was writing another series based in Osten Ard, the first of them recently released, but having seen it physically in the bookstore, i was dismayed at how thin it was – almost novella length. Not sure what i’ll do about that, maybe wait until the other two are done.

    Slightly more recently for me, Robin Hobbes’ return to the Assassin series has finished its third book, that’s up there with the same excitement level for me. It’s not MST, but i’m keen to dive back into her stories too.

    • Zack Matzo (@perch15) says:

      The Heart of What Was Lost is kind of a “bridge” novella. The new trilogy hasn’t started in earnest yet. First book comes out on 6/27 (in the States anyway…). Thanks for reading and commenting!

  6. Toby Frost says:

    They’re great books, some of the most engrossing fantasy that I’ve ever read. I think Williams did a very good job of putting fresh life into some quite “normal” fantasy tropes. They’ve got a really three-dimensional, solid feel that I like a lot. They are a bit overlong to my mind, and the pace really sags at points, but overall I enjoyed them very much.

    A couple of years ago I wrote a short article about the series. It’s here if you’re interested: https://www.sffchronicles.com/threads/548945/

  7. […] Zachary A. Matzo at Fantasy Faction calls Memory, Sorrow and Thorn “essential reading for any fan of the fantastic” in his appreciation. […]

Leave a Comment