Fantasy Faction

Fantasy Faction => Fantasy Book & Author Discussion => Topic started by: eclipse on October 15, 2019, 06:47:22 AM

Title: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: eclipse on October 15, 2019, 06:47:22 AM
I’ve read the

Grace of Kings, it didn’t blow me away

The tea master and the detective, again didn’t impress me

Green Bone saga , quite like this one

Have got the Black tides of Heaven by J.Y Yang on my Tbr list
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: ScarletBea on October 15, 2019, 07:57:25 AM
*what* is 'silkpunk'?? :o

From some of your names it looks to be books set in an alternative Asia (instead of the usual alternative Europe), is that it?
Seems a strange name to call...
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: S. K. Inkslinger on October 15, 2019, 08:13:52 AM
Lol, silkpunk.  ;D As suggestions goes, I'd tossed you my novel, "When Crows Cawed".
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: eclipse on October 15, 2019, 08:28:07 AM
*what* is 'silkpunk'?? :o

From some of your names it looks to be books set in an alternative Asia (instead of the usual alternative Europe), is that it?
Seems a strange name to call...


 https://io9.gizmodo.com/author-ken-liu-explains-silkpunk-to-us-1717812714/amp
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: ScarletBea on October 15, 2019, 09:44:13 AM
Thanks, I get it now.
And I haven't read any book in this genre.
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: cupiscent on October 15, 2019, 11:50:17 AM
I was going to link that article as well, hah. :D

Having heard Ken Liu talk a lot at the Melbourne convention this year (where he was a Guest of Honour) I am newly interested in going back to the Grace of Kings / Dandelion Dynasty world. But the books are just so massive! I won't do it for Sanderson, and I'm not sure I can persuade myself to do it for Liu either, even if he's an amazing renaissance man.

I'm very much looking forward to getting into the Tensorate series. So many books, so little time.

Jade Bone feels less "silkpunk" and more... urban fantasy? Gangster wuxia? But hey, labels are mutable, so why not!
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: eclipse on October 15, 2019, 11:59:38 AM
I’m not strict with my labels  :)

The throne of the five winds looks interesting but 750 page count ....
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: cupiscent on October 16, 2019, 10:50:44 PM
Gosh yes, I'm looking forward to Throne of Five Winds (even at that page count - Priory of the Orange Tree was big too but SO worth it).

Though seeing the comparisons to K Arsenault Rivera in the description of ToFW made me wonder... why not include The Tiger's Daughter et al in silkpunk? And I guess the answer is because Asian as that setting it, the books are clearly fantasy, straight fantasy, no technology/sci-fi blurring. (Ditto Elizabeth Bear's Mongolian / central Asian fantasies.) So the silkpunk needs a bit of that "steampunk but Asian not Victorian" element to it.
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: Elfy on October 17, 2019, 06:40:10 AM
I was going to link that article as well, hah. :D

Having heard Ken Liu talk a lot at the Melbourne convention this year (where he was a Guest of Honour) I am newly interested in going back to the Grace of Kings / Dandelion Dynasty world. But the books are just so massive! I won't do it for Sanderson, and I'm not sure I can persuade myself to do it for Liu either, even if he's an amazing renaissance man.

I'm very much looking forward to getting into the Tensorate series. So many books, so little time.

Jade Bone feels less "silkpunk" and more... urban fantasy? Gangster wuxia? But hey, labels are mutable, so why not!
I’m reading Jade War the 2nd book of the Green Bone series and it’s closer to how @cupiscent describes it than how ‘silkpunk’ is supposedly described.
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: eclipse on December 14, 2019, 08:02:09 PM
Gosh yes, I'm looking forward to Throne of Five Winds (even at that page count - Priory of the Orange Tree was big too but SO worth it).


I’m loving Throne of Five Winds thank you for mentioning this title , I love the court intrigues and I’m in love with Lady Komor.

There’s no magic  or military battles  in this book so not everyone will like it.
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: isos81 on December 14, 2019, 08:04:32 PM
There’s no magic

That ended it up for me :)
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: eclipse on December 14, 2019, 08:11:59 PM
There’s no magic

That ended it up for me :)

Thought I best mention that hehe. Who needs complex magic systems over plots and character development  😛
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: cupiscent on December 14, 2019, 10:27:17 PM
I’m loving Throne of Five Winds thank you for mentioning this title , I love the court intrigues and I’m in love with Lady Komor.

There’s no magic  or military battles  in this book so not everyone will like it.

Court intrigues? Awesome ladies? No battles? This sounds so much like my sort of thing that I might just have to go buy it.
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: Peat on December 14, 2019, 10:46:58 PM
I was going to link that article as well, hah. :D

Having heard Ken Liu talk a lot at the Melbourne convention this year (where he was a Guest of Honour) I am newly interested in going back to the Grace of Kings / Dandelion Dynasty world. But the books are just so massive! I won't do it for Sanderson, and I'm not sure I can persuade myself to do it for Liu either, even if he's an amazing renaissance man.

I'm very much looking forward to getting into the Tensorate series. So many books, so little time.

Jade Bone feels less "silkpunk" and more... urban fantasy? Gangster wuxia? But hey, labels are mutable, so why not!
I’m reading Jade War the 2nd book of the Green Bone series and it’s closer to how @cupiscent describes it than how ‘silkpunk’ is supposedly described.

I will third this - unless Silkpunk is used for generic vaguely Eastern Asian vaguely technological, I don't think Green Bones is.

That said, that's about how well used all other X-punk labels are used, not to mention that most X-punk genres are poorly named to begin with due to being about as punk as a Shell PR meeting, so why the devil not.

Using the loose definition, Jay Kristoff's Stormdancer series is vaguely in the right place. But not that great anyway.
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: eclipse on February 14, 2020, 06:35:39 AM
I’m loving Throne of Five Winds thank you for mentioning this title , I love the court intrigues and I’m in love with Lady Komor.

There’s no magic  or military battles  in this book so not everyone will like it.

Court intrigues? Awesome ladies? No battles? This sounds so much like my sort of thing that I might just have to go buy it.

I see you enjoying this one @cupiscent  ;D
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: cupiscent on February 14, 2020, 10:06:38 AM
I’m loving Throne of Five Winds thank you for mentioning this title , I love the court intrigues and I’m in love with Lady Komor.

There’s no magic  or military battles  in this book so not everyone will like it.

Court intrigues? Awesome ladies? No battles? This sounds so much like my sort of thing that I might just have to go buy it.

I see you enjoying this one @cupiscent  ;D

Loving it! It's not perfect - I think it probably doesn't need to be as long (and lush) as it is and sometimes the author gets a bit lost in her descriptive detail. (A problem I've had with Lilith Saintcrow before, but it works better for her in this setting.) In fact, it's amusing reading this thread again, because I'd forgotten about its page count, so when the guy at the bookstore thumped it down on the counter I went, "...oh." The last two things I read were nice and short! ;D

But the politics! The refined control on everyone! The scalding poetry-quoting cutting remarks! The epic queen bitch! I love everyone in this bar.
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: eclipse on February 22, 2020, 09:46:52 AM
Now we just need book two  ;D

Give me more court intrigue and Lady Komor
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: cupiscent on February 23, 2020, 05:13:09 AM
Now we just need book two  ;D

Give me more court intrigue and Lady Komor

I went immediately upon finishing to trawl Lili Saintcrow's social media to see if there were any hints of when we could expect book 2, and was pretty devo not to find anything. (I wish to note that I absolutely love Prince Takshin, but I am 100% Team Kai when it comes to Romancing Lady Komor.)
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: cupiscent on August 03, 2020, 06:20:39 AM
Swinging through here because Fonda Lee tweeted about silkpunk, and feeling very like @eclipse in seeing that "Warning: this topic has not been posted in for at least 120 days" note. :D

Says Fonda Lee (https://twitter.com/FondaJLee/status/1290040182641582080):
Quote
"Silkpunk" is a term coined by the brilliant Ken Liu to describe a blend of sci-fi and fantasy inspired not by Victorian-era steam-powered technology ("steampunk") but by East Asian antiquity. It does NOT apply to every SFF story inspired by Asian history or culture.

I mean, shouting about what people want to label things is always a shaking-fist-at-cloud sort of scenario, but in this situation I feel that there's a nuance to the use or misuse of subgenre labelling to do with the minimisation or othering of an entire race-related body of work. i.e. "let's not talk about the details of what the work is and does; it's Asian and that's the only thing that matters".

As Lee further said in that twitter thread:
Quote
Leaving aside the issue of '-punk' being egregiously and erroneously overused *in general* - taking a term for a specific fictional aesthetic and lumping in all Asia-inspired works (or works by authors of Asian descent) simplifes, misrepresents, and flattens a huge range of work.

In the responses to this little thread, there's someone contemplating writing a piece for Fantasy Faction about the nuances of subgenres especially for "diverse" authors, and I definitely hope that happens!

What I'm uncertain about is whether the SC Emmett fits the bill. Sure, no magic, but also no real technological edge. It's just... non-magic fantasy?
Title: Re: Which silkpunk novels would you recommend?
Post by: eclipse on August 03, 2020, 02:43:17 PM
Now we just need book two  ;D

Give me more court intrigue and Lady Komor

I went immediately upon finishing to trawl Lili Saintcrow's social media to see if there were any hints of when we could expect book 2, and was pretty devo not to find anything. (I wish to note that I absolutely love Prince Takshin, but I am 100% Team Kai when it comes to Romancing Lady Komor.)

we want book 2, we want book 2.