The pre-dawn air turned to frost as it touched the deeper cold of Peter Manlove’s heart. Peter’s son, Albert, his second for the morning’s bleak business, misidentified the source of the chill and turned up his collar against the modest breeze.
At a jerk of his father’s chin, Albert drew a night-black box from the bag at their feet. He lifted the lid, revealing an even blacker weapon, nestled in red velvet. An awful thing, and the duels it fought more awful still. Albert couldn’t remember when he’d last seen his father with a gun. The Robertson’s estate? When Albert was a boy. The guns booming, and the bloodied pheasants drifting down like autumn leaves. Mother had been with them then. She’d held young Albert as he’d wept and known he was no man.
The bone grip of the dueler warmed like a live thing in Albert’s palm. He passed it to his father quickly. Next to the dueling pistol’s now-empty recess rested a smaller, single-shot device for extremely close range, the Coward’s Remedy. The thought of it made Albert ill. He wanted all this over. “You could -“ he began.
Peter Manlove snorted, raising the gun and sighting across the barrel. “Apologize? Turn womanly? Martin Anklesmith is a coward, a thief, and a murderer. It’s no insult to name a man for what he is.” He drew the Bullet from its blood-red velvet pouch, and stared into its depths. Black on black on black. “Thirty years,” he whispered. “It ends now.” He told the Bullet all his hate.
Across the twilit meadow, pregnant now with subtle golds and green, Martin Anklesmith took a twin of the dueler from his own son’s firm grip.
“I’m proud of you, Father,” said Andre. Martin wished he believed him. His son’s disdain was a long-established thing. “Calling that dog out was an act of true honor.” An act of true idiocy, thought Martin. It was Andre who’d talked him into it. Well, no, he’d talked himself into it. But the insult! The accusation! Of course he’d had to act. He’d not have been able to show himself to his friends, after Manlove had so publicly slandered him. But no, it wasn’t about his friends. It was about her. How could he ever speak to her again, ever visit her grave, ever walk with her in memory unless he took this final step.
Andre straightened his collar. So tall. Strong. Any father would be proud. Mariah’s beauty looked out from their son’s features, though none of her tenderness. Martin knew where the poison came from. Hate blackens everything. And, oh, how he’d nursed his hate. Giving it up had been the only gift he’d ever held back from his wife.
Martin took the Bullet from Andre and held it up between thumb and forefinger. Mariah’s image filled the vacant dark of his vision: the night she left that fiend Manlove and pounded on his door, bleeding, bruised. Martin had gone for his hunting rifle, intent on murder. She’d held him back with a word. She would never have wanted... this. He sagged.
“No!” Andre hissed, gripping his father’s shoulders. “No, you don’t. I wrote very the challenge for you. I delivered it. I sought out the dueling guns.” His breath stank of wine. How early had he started? “I brought you here. I even drove the carriage. All you have to do is squeeze the trigger!”
A sudden, panicky humor took Martin. “Maybe you should, Andre. You have enough anger for us both.”
Andre’s slap caught Martin with a burst of pain. He raised the gun between them, heart pounding. It shook at the end of his hand, an inch from Andre’s face. Sllowly, he noticed the barrel of the Coward’s Remedy staring unwaveringly into his own eye.
Andre smiled. Lowering his own weapon, he pushed his father’s aside and stepped in close. “Across this field is a man you’ve hated all your life. He’s beaten you at everything, except the one thing that mattered. So what did he do? He paid off mother’s doctor -“ Martin paled. “What? Didn’t you suspect?”
“No, that’s not -“
“Not possible? Not possible that Peter Manlove killed my mother? Not possible that you were so stupid that you didn’t notice the doctor switch her medicine?” Martin stared horror-struck. “And then that monster accused you of letting her die! Wanting her inheritance for yourself, since God knows you’ve made a disaster of every business you tried.”
“No,” Martin protested, his heart wrenched with grief and shame.
“Finish it.” Andre forced Martin’s fingers around the cold, heavy ball of the Bullet. “Tell it everything. Give it so much hate it can’t miss.”
They met at the center of the field, a gathered darkness, though the dawn at last set all the colors glowing. The half-brothers greeted each other stiffly, sons of the same mother, but as different as their fathers.
Manlove towered over Anklesmith, pressing close so Martin had to crane his head to meet his eyes. Martin had always believed that the source of the man’s hatred, more than Mariah’s actual rejection, was that he lost her to a man who was modest in every way.
“Nothing to say?” snarled Manlove. He curled his lip in an expression so planned that Martin nearly laughed. Relief flooded him. The bastard wanted a confrontation, wanted an excuse to talk, brag. Martin stepped back. He raised his Bullet and let its power speak for him. Manlove went to show his, but Martin turned his back on him and walked to his spot five yards away.
“Coward!” Manlove threw after him. “Did you see that?” he said to Albert. “Wouldn’t even face me.” Albert thought the man showed bravery, but he kept his opinion to himself. His father took a moment to bask in the pleasure of cowing his enemy, then sauntered to his place.
The brothers watched the two men prepare their pistols. Each placed his Bullet into the chamber and snapped the gun closed.
“You know what to do?” Andre said to Albert.
“Yes.” Andre was nearly as tall Albert’s his own father.And beautiful. “But there should be a better way than this.”
“Not after what they did to our mother.” Andre patted his shoulder. “Now go, take your place.”
Albert stood three paces behind his father, as Andre stood behind his. Each slid a fat but unmagik’d lead ball into the maw of his Coward’s Remedy, standing ready to take his own father’s life if he shied away from the duel’s conclusion.
A deceptive silence fell, then was broken by Andre’s harsh voice. “Honor demands that we allow you the opportunity of apology.”
“Get on with it, boy!” answered Manlove. “You are the son of a coward, and you’ll always be known for it.” From the distance of over thirty feet, Albert saw his half-brother’s face redden. Yes. It was easy to hate Peter Manlove after just a few minutes acquaintance. Imagine a lifetime.
There were more words. Rituals of accusation and dispute, then an incantation to activate the Bullets. The weird syllables had taken much work to memorize. There was something ridiculous about it all, if it hadn’t been so deadly. Albert was almost shocked when the two enemies’ arms rose and the guns thundered. He raised his own gun and focused on his father’s head while the Bullets swerved to an unerring embrace.
The Bullets met with a sharp crack, then hung in the air, unmoving. At first, nothing happened. Then black light flared from Peter Manlove’s Bullet, tendrils of energy reaching around to absorb the other ball. Manlove crowed. Albert couldn’t help feeling relief.
Golden light broke through the black shell, the hateful tendrils retreating. Martin’s Bullet forced its opposite the barest inch toward where Manlove cheered it on. Then another inch, and another.
Love, thought Martin Anklesmith. He’d whispered love to his Bullet. Mariah’s love. So much more powerful than hate. Love pushed Peter’s Bullet back and back. The man was screaming in fear now. Just a few more feet. Martin wished he wanted the bullet to stop, to spare the man, but he didn’t.
Manlove broke and ran. And as he did, Albert shot his father in the back, the Remedy blowing a whole through the man’s heart.
It was over. At last. Martin felt -
He never heard the blast of Andre’s weapon. He was dead before his body crumpled to the ground.
The brothers met between the bodies sprawled in the fallen leaves.
“I wasn’t sure you’d actually do it,” Andre said.
Albert shook, his teeth rattling. “One of us,” he started, breathed, then started again. “One of us had to do murder.”
“And you’re glad it wasn’t you? I’m no more a murderer than you. You shot a coward, and so did I. Mother would be proud.” Andre stretched out his hand. Albert took it, since he didn’t know how to refuse.
So that they wouldn’t hate themselves, they started to hate each other.